| 1 |
Barbara Cook in
The Music Man?

Cook was considered to repeat her Tony winning role of Marion the Librarian, but Jones was considered a movie star and Cook had not made any movies. Cook was hurt by this for many years. |
| 2 |
Ruth Warwick in
Carrie (1952)?

Warwick was originally cast in this film. |
| 3 |
Carrie Fisher in
Superman?

Fresh off of Star Wars, Carrie Fisher was said to be considered to play Lois Lane. |
| 4 |
Irene Dunne in
Valiant Is The Word for Carrie?

Dunne turned down the title role. |
| 5 |
Michael Keaton in
Leap of Faith?

Steve Martin took over the lead role after Michael Keaton quit. |
| 6 |
Ann Miller in
Singin' in The Rain?

In 1950, Miller was announced for the role of Kathy, but it was eventually played by Debbie Reynolds. |
| 7 |
Sigourney Weaver in
Then She Found Me?

Weaver originally optioned the rights to this book in 1989 and wanted to star in it but the project was never made and Weaver became to old for the lead character. |
| 8 |
Johnny Depp in
State of Play?

Was among the actors considered when Brad Pitt dropped out. |
| 9 |
Tom Hanks in
State of Play?

One of the stars considered after Brad Pitt dropped out of the film. |
| 10 |
Elliott Gould in
Deconstructing Harry?

Gould was being strongly considered by Woody Allen for the title role. He turned it down due to a scheduling conflict. |
| 11 |
Elliott Gould in
Portnoy's Complaint?

Gould turned down the starring role. |
| 12 |
Elliott Gould in
Straw Dogs?

Gould turned down the opportunity to play David Sumner. |
| 13 |
Ginger Rogers in
Carrie (1952)?

Rogers was the first choice to play this role in the early 1940's, but when it was made in the early 1950's she was no longer age appropriate. |
| 14 |
Irene Dunne in
Carrie (1952)?

Dunne was considered for this role when it was to be made by RKO in the early 1940's, but she did not see how it could be made well without censoring the story and so declined it. As it was, it was not made for another 10 years. |
| 15 |
Katharine Hepburn in
Bloomer Girl?

This movie was supposed to be made in the 1960's with Shirley MacLaine as Evalina and Hepburn as her Aunt Dolly Bloomer, who designed the famous Bloomer pants. The movie of the Broadway musical was not made. |
| 16 |
Myrna Loy in
Blithe Spirit?

Loy was offered the part of Elvira, a part she felt she was "born to play," but MGM would not loan her out. |
| 17 |
Kathryn Grayson in
Because You're Mine?

Grayson refused to work with Mario Lanza due to his rude behavior on her two films with him, so MGM brought in Broadway ingenue Doretta Morrow and he was horrible to her too. She refused to make another film after that and never did. |
| 18 |
Shirley Temple in
Barnacle Bill?

Temple was thought of for this movie, but her mother thought Wallace Beery was too much of a scene stealer and so Shirley did not make this movie. |
| 19 |
Janet Gaynor in
Banjo on My Knee?

This movie was originally intended for Gaynor, but starred the more box office friendly Stanwyck. |
| 20 |
Gloria Grahame in
Bad Men of Tombstone?

Gloria Grahame rejected the role of Julie in this B movie. |
| 21 |
Virginia McKenna in
North By Northwest?

According to Lewis Gilbert at a National Theatre Interview, Virginia McKenna was asked to play Eve in North By Northwest. |
| 22 |
Rod Taylor in
The French Connection?

Eddie Egan, the real-life "Popeye Doyle," wanted Taylor for the role, but director William Friedkin eventually went with Gene Hackman. |
| 23 |
Alicia Silverstone in
The Opposite of Sex?

Alicia Silverstone was originally set to play the lead but dropped out to do another film. |
| 24 |
Chloe Sevigny in
Mona Lisa Smile?

Chloe Sevigny auditioned unsuccessfully for the role of Giselle Levy. |
| 25 |
Claire Danes in
Dazed and Confused?

Danes auditioned for the role of Sabrina Davis but was considered "too classy" by the director. |