notstarring.com notstarring.com
Find your favorite actors or movies:
Browse By Actor: “P” LIST CLOUD DETAILS
Browse by Actor
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ Other
Click below to see which actors turned down roles in your favorite films. Where does this sort of trivia come from? Movie fans from around the world submit fun trivia to us from TV interviews, books, magazine articles, DVD commentary, and other entertainment sources around the Internet.

 Al Pacino BACK TO TOP  
Angel Heart
Pacino was considered to play Harry Parker.
Actor who got the part: Mickey Rourke

Apocalypse Now
Considered for the part of Willard.
Actor who got the part: Martin Sheen

Bang the Drum Slowly
Pacino was cast to play the doomed baseball catcher, Bruce Pearson, but he left the role for "the Godfather". Copolla suggested DiNiro as a replacement.
Actor who got the part: Robert DiNiro

Beverly Hills Cop
Pacino was considered for role of Axel Foley.
Actor who got the part: Eddie Murphy

Born on The Fourth of July
Pacino was cast in this film before Oliver Stone directed "Platoon" The movie was set to go with another director (with Stone writing the screenplay) when financing fell through.
Actor who got the part: Tom Cruise

Brother Sun, Sister Moon
Pacino tested but was rejected by the director (Franco Zeffirelli), who disliked his acting style.
Actor who got the part: Graham Faulkner

Close Encounters of the Third Kind
Al Pacino turned down lead for the role Roy Neary.
Actor who got the part: Richard Dreyfuss

Coming Home
Al Pacino was considered to play Luke Martin.
Actor who got the part: Jon Voight

Crimson Tide
Al Pacino turned down the lead role.
Actor who got the part: Gene Hackman

Days of Heaven
Al Pacino turned down the lead role.
Actor who got the part: Richard Gere

Family Plot
Alfred Hitchcock considered Pacino to play the cab driver who stumbles on a complicated kidnap and thievery plot.
Actor who got the part: Bruce Dern

First Blood
Al Pacino was considered to play Rambo.

Funny Lady
Al Pacino was considered for the part of Billy Rose opposite Streisand.
Actor who got the part: James Caan

Get Shorty
Al Pacino was considered to play Chili Palmer.
Actor who got the part: John Travolta

Johnny Handsome
Pacino was originally attached to play the title character and worked on developing the script, but ultimately passed on the role.
Actor who got the part: Mickey Rourke

Kramer vs. Kramer
Al Pacino turned down the role of Ted Kramer.
Actor who got the part: Dustin Hoffman

Lenny
Pacino was considered for the role of Lenny Bruce.
Actor who got the part: Dustin Hoffman

Love Me or Leave Me
The actor was often mentioned as the likely co-star with Winona Ryder in a remake of the 1955 musical biography of torch singer Ruth Etting's relationship with a gangster.
Actor who got the part: Project Abandoned

Marathon Man
John Schlesinger wanted Al Pacino and Julie Christie to co-star in this production. Robert Evans insisted that Dustin Hoffman be cast.
Actor who got the part: Dustin Hoffman

Midnight Cowboy
Pacino was scheduled to make an appearance as a Vietnam vet but couldn't fit it in his schedule.

Misery
Al Pacino turned down the lead role.
Actor who got the part: James Caan

The Pope of Greenwich Village
In an interview with Leonard Maltin on ET while promoting 'Heat' back in 1995, Pacino & DeNiro said they were offered the lead roles in TPOGV, but it didn't work out for some reason.
Actor who got the part: Eric Roberts & Mickey Rourke

Pretty Woman
Al Pacino was offered the lead role of Edward.
Actor who got the part: Richard Gere

RKO 281
Al Pacino was considered to replace Dustin Hoffman in the role of Herman J. Mankiewicz. The film was eventually scaled down to a TV movie.
Actor who got the part: John Malkovich

Slap Shot
Lost out on the lead role of the coach-player because he thought director George Roy Hill "facetious" when he asked if he could ice skate.
Actor who got the part: Paul Newman

Snake Eyes
Was originally cast to play the role of Commander Kevin Dunne.
Actor who got the part: Gary Sinise

Star Wars
Supposedly turned down the role of Han Solo in Star Wars.
Actor who got the part: Harrison Ford

Taxi Driver
Al Pacino turned down the role of Travis Bickle.
Actor who got the part: Robert DeNiro

Traffic
Pacino turned down the role of Judge Wakefield.
Actor who got the part: Michael Douglas

The Usual Suspects
He turned down the role of Dave Kujan because he was already playing a cop in another movie around that time.
Actor who got the part: Chazz Palminteri


 Joanna Pacula BACK TO TOP  
Cat People (1982)
The striking Polish-born accent was considered for the role of Irena.
Actor who got the part: Nastassja Kinski


 Sarah Padden BACK TO TOP  
The Wizard of Oz
Sarah Padden was considered for Auntie Em, according to The Wizard of Oz Pictorial History-50th anniversary edition book.
Actor who got the part: Clara Blandick


 Geraldine Page BACK TO TOP  
Agnes of God
Geraldine Page originated the role of Mother Miriam Ruth in the Broadway play by John Pielmeier, but was overlooked for the film.
Actor who got the part: Anne Bancroft

The Exorcist
Geraldine reportedly turned down the part of Chris MacNeil.
Actor who got the part: Ellen Burstyn

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
Page was considered for the role of Ratched.
Actor who got the part: Louise Fletcher


 Elaine Paige BACK TO TOP  
Evita
Elaine Paige originated the role of Eva Peron in the Andrew Lloyd Webber/Tim Rice musical in London, but she was passed over for the film version as she had no name in Hollywood.
Actor who got the part: Madonna


 Janis Paige BACK TO TOP  
The Pajama Game
Missed out on repeating for films her Broadway stage role when box-office attraction Frank Sinatra passed on playing the male lead.
Actor who got the part: Doris Day


 Holly Palance BACK TO TOP  
Superman
She was considered for the role of Lois Lane and was eventually used to screen test other actors, including Christopher Reeve, for the role of Clark Kent.
Actor who got the part: Margot Kidder


 Jack Palance BACK TO TOP  
The Day the Earth Stood Still
Studio titan Daryl F. Zanuck suggested Palance for the role of the robot "Gort."
Actor who got the part: Lock Martin

The Dirty Dozen
Palance turned down the role of Archer J. Maggott.
Actor who got the part: Telly Savalas

The Man with the Golden Gun
The title role of Scaramanga, was orignally offered to Jack Palance.
Actor who got the part: Christopher Lee


 Michael Palin BACK TO TOP  
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen
Palin was originally slated to play the Prime Minister of the Moon, but budget contraints cut out the planned sequence.
Actor who got the part: None / Scenes Cut

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Michael Palin was considered for the role of Willy Wonka.
Actor who got the part: Johnny Depp


 Brian De Palma BACK TO TOP  
Flashdance
Palma was originally going to direct but left the film to do Scarface instead.


 Betsy Palmer BACK TO TOP  
Freddy vs. Jason
Betsy Palmer was asked to reprise her role of Mrs.Voorhees but reportedly turned it when they could not reach a salary agreement.


 Gwyneth Paltrow BACK TO TOP  
13 Going On 30
Was considered for the role which eventually went to Jennifer Garner.
Actor who got the part: Jennifer Garner

The Avengers
Gwyneth Paltrow turned down the role of Emma Peel.
Actor who got the part: Uma Thurman

The Aviator
Had originally agreed to play Ava Gardner but dropped out.

Bewitched
Gwyneth Paltrow was considered to play Samantha.
Actor who got the part: Nicole Kidman

Boogie Nights
Gwyneth Paltrow turned down an offer to play Rollergirl.
Actor who got the part: Heather Graham

Chicago
Gwyneth Paltrow was considered for the role of Roxie.
Actor who got the part: Renee Zellweger

Cool as Ice
Gwyneth Paltrow was offered and turned down the role of Kathy, due to her father's insitence.
Actor who got the part: Kristin Minter

Feeling Minnesota
Paltrow dropped out - Diaz was the second choice.
Actor who got the part: Cameron Diaz

The Hours
Was supposed to play Julianne Moore's housewife role.
Actor who got the part: Julianne Moore

How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days
She was originally supposed to play Andie Anderson but pulled out.
Actor who got the part: Kate Hudson

I Heart Huckabees
Scheduled to play "Dawn Campbell," she dropped out of the project for personal reasons.
Actor who got the part: Naomi Watts

The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou
Gwyneth Paltrow was not able to play the lead due to scheduling conflict.
Actor who got the part: Cate Blanchett

Pearl Harbor
Producers also wanted Paltrow as the female lead, but a schedule conflict prevented her from doing the movie.

The Ring
Gwyneth Paltrow turned down the role of Rachel.
Actor who got the part: Naomi Watts

Secretary
Gwyneth Paltrow was originally set to play Lee Holloway.
Actor who got the part: Maggie Gyllenhaal

Titanic
The part of Rose was originally offered to Gwyneth Paltrow.


 Hayden Panettiere BACK TO TOP  
Panic Room
Panettiere was cast as Sarah Altman in Panic Room but was replaced by Kristen Stewart when Jodie Foster replaced Nicole Kidman as her mother.
Actor who got the part: Kristen Stewart


 Anna Paquin BACK TO TOP  
Waterworld
Anna Paquin was the first choice to play Enola.
Actor who got the part: Tina Majorino


 Eleanor Parke BACK TO TOP  
The Country Girl
Parker wanted to play Georgie Elgin and was one of the actresses considered, but a younger and less expensive Grace Kelly won the role and got an Oscar.
Actor who got the part: Grace Kelly


 Alan Parker BACK TO TOP  
The Wiz
Alan Parker was approached to direct, but passed.
Actor who got the part: Sidney Lumet


 Eleanor Parker BACK TO TOP  
Executive Suite
Eleanor Parker reportedly did not consider the part big enough.
Actor who got the part: Barbara Stanwyck

Friendly Persuasion
Many actresses were considered for this part, including Parker.
Actor who got the part: Dorothy McGuire

Old Acquaintance
Vincent Sherman wanted Eleanor Parker for the part of Dierdre.
Actor who got the part: Dolores Moran


 Fess Parker BACK TO TOP  
Bus Stop
The producers of "Bus Stop" wanted Fess Parker for the role of the young cowboy; Walt Disney, who owned Parker's contract, declined to loan the actor out.
Actor who got the part: Don Murray

The Searchers
John Ford went to Walt Disney to get Fess Parker for the role of Martin, but Disney wouldn't let Parker do it. Parker didn't know of this for several years.
Actor who got the part: Jeffrey Hunter


 Sarah Jessica Parker BACK TO TOP  
Four Weddings and a Funeral
Sarah Jessica Parker reportedly was considered for the role of Carrie.
Actor who got the part: Andie Macdowell

My Best Friend's Wedding
Auditioned for the lead part and did not get it.
Actor who got the part: Julia Roberts

Vacancy
Had been set to star in the thriller about a married couple stranded at an isolated motel.
Actor who got the part: Kate Beckinsale


 Barbara Parkins BACK TO TOP  
The Disappearance
Barbara was replaced before filming began.
Actor who got the part: Francine Racette

Love Story
Barbara Parkins admitted at a conference that she turned down the lead female role in this film.
Actor who got the part: Ali MacGraw

They Shoot Horses, Don't They?
Barbara Parkins admitted at a conference, that she turned down the role of "Alice," eventually played by Susannah York.
Actor who got the part: Susannah York

Valley of the Dolls
Parkins screen tested for Neely O'Hara but ended up playing Anne Welles instead.
Actor who got the part: Patty Duke


 Dolly Parton BACK TO TOP  
The Dukes of Hazzard
Dolly Parton turned down the role of Pauline.
Actor who got the part: Lynda Carter

Educating Rita
American backers wanted director Lewis Gilbert to cast Dolly as Rita, because Julie Walters had only done TV up to that time.
Actor who got the part: Julie Walters

Supergirl
The role of Selina was originally to be played by Parton. Production materials were even printed describing her role in the film.
Actor who got the part: Faye Dunaway


 Ivan Passer BACK TO TOP  
Yentl
Ivan Passer was attached to direct this film, entitled Masquerade, in 1971, but left the project. Streisand said in her Making of Yentl documentary that Passer refused to cast her as Yentl because she was too old.
Actor who got the part: Barbra Streisand


 Mandy Patinkin BACK TO TOP  
Heartburn
Fired after rehearsals made director Mike Nichols see the lack of chemistry between Patinkin and Meryl Streep.
Actor who got the part: Jack Nicholson

Heartburn
Originally cast as Mark, opposite Meryl Streep, but fired by director Mike Nichols.
Actor who got the part: Jack Nicholson

Manhunter
Mandy Patinkin was considered to play Hannibal in Manhunter.
Actor who got the part: Brian Cox


 Jason Patric BACK TO TOP  
Braveheart
Gibson actually wanted to cast Jason Patric in the lead role of William Wallace.
Actor who got the part: Mel Gibson

The Doors
Patric was considered to play Jim Morrison.
Actor who got the part: Val Kilmer

The Firm
Turned down the role of young lawyer "Mitch McDeere" in the big hit thriller.
Actor who got the part: Tom Cruise

The Passion of the Christ
Turned down the lead role of "Jesus" in Mel Gibson's movie.
Actor who got the part: James Caviezel


 Lee Patrick BACK TO TOP  
The Roaring Twenties
Was considered to play "Panama Smith," the gutsy, sentimental, tough nightclub hostess.
Actor who got the part: Gladys George


 Alexandra Paul BACK TO TOP  
The Princess Bride
Alexandra Paul auditioned for the role of Buttercup.
Actor who got the part: Robin Wright Penn


 Bill Paxton BACK TO TOP  
The Da Vinci Code
Bill Paxton was Ron Howard's first choice to star as Robert Langdon.
Actor who got the part: Tom Hanks


 John Payne BACK TO TOP  
Moonraker
In 1955, John Payne (Fred from Miracle on 34th Street) paid a $1,000/month option for 9 months on the Bond novel Moonraker. He eventually gave up the option when he learned he couldn't retain the rights for the entire series of Bond novels.
Actor who got the part: Roger Moore


 Guy Pearce BACK TO TOP  
Batman Begins
Pearce was turned down for the role of Batman.
Actor who got the part: Christian Bale

Daredevil
Guy Pearce turned down the lead role.
Actor who got the part: Ben Affleck

Eragon
Guy Pearce was reportedly considered for the role of Durza the Shade.


 Gregory Peck BACK TO TOP  
Batman (1946)
Director Orson Welles seriously considered making a Batman movie in 1946, for which the studio wanted Gregory Peck to play Bruce Wayne.
Actor who got the part: Never Made

Cape Fear (1962)
Was approached to play the psychotic and sadistic villain "Max Cady," but instead wanted the more heroic role.
Actor who got the part: Robert Mitchum

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Gregory Peck was offered the role of Grandpa Joe but passed away before accepting. His family have said that he was excited about playing Grandpa Joe.
Actor who got the part: David Kelly

High Noon
Peck was offered the Will Kane role, but didn't want to do another western after the boxoffice failure of "The Gunfighter". It may of also had to do with the fact that scriptwriter Carl Foreman was about to be blacklisted.
Actor who got the part: Gary Cooper

How to Steal a Million
Master director William Wyler first wanted to reteam his "Roman Holiday" stars Gregory Peck and Audrey Hepburn.
Actor who got the part: Peter O'Toole

Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Gregory Peck was considered for the role of Prof. Henry Jones.
Actor who got the part: Sean Connery

North By Northwest
Peck was considered by Hitchcock for the lead role.
Actor who got the part: Cary Grant

Quo Vadis
The granite faced star was originally cast as Marcus Vinicius in this Biblical epic.
Actor who got the part: Robert Taylor

Ryan's Daughter
Was enthusiastic to accept the role of Charles Shuaugnessy but David Lean turned him down.
Actor who got the part: Robert Mitchum

The Wild Bunch
Turned down the role of "Pike Bishop."
Actor who got the part: William Holden


 Sam Peckinpah BACK TO TOP  
Superman
Director Sam Peckinpah was considered by producer Ilya Salkind to direct Superman.


 Kal Penn BACK TO TOP  
Grindhouse
In a 2006 interview, Kal Penn (star of Harold and Kumar) said he auditioned for Tarantino but was unable to commit to the part because Grindhouse production conflicted with the filming of Epic Movie.


 Robin Wright Penn BACK TO TOP  
The Sure Thing
Robin Wright Penn auditioned for the role of The Sure Thing.
Actor who got the part: Nicollette Sheridan


 Sean Penn BACK TO TOP  
Blind Date
Was considered for the role of Walter opposite Madonna but producers wanted Willis.
Actor who got the part: Bruce Willis

Factotum
Sean Penn was first choice for the role of Henry.
Actor who got the part: Matt Dillon

Fight Club
Sean Penn was seriously considered to play the title role of Tyler Durden.
Actor who got the part: Brad Pitt

Great Balls of Fire!
Sean Penn was considered to star at one point.
Actor who got the part: Dennis Quaid

Once Upon a Time in Mexico
Sean Penn turned down the role of Sands.
Actor who got the part: Johnny Depp

Punch-Drunk Love
Sean Penn was reportedly considered for the role of Dean Trumbell.
Actor who got the part: Phillip Seymour Hoffman

Red Dragon
Penn was considered for the role of Dolarhyde.
Actor who got the part: Ralph Fiennes

Red Eye
This film was written with Sean Penn in mind, but Craven chose to go with younger leads.
Actor who got the part: Cillian Murphy

Risky Business
According to a VH1 "Behind the Movie" documentary, Penn was one of the actors who were considered for a role in this movie.

Superman Lives
When Kevin Smith was writing the script, producer Jon Peters told him that he thought Sean Penn should play Superman after he saw him in Dead Man Walking claiming that Penn had that caged killer instinct that would be perfect for the role.


 George Peppard BACK TO TOP  
The Killers (1964)
George Peppard was on a list of actors considered for the role of Johnny North.
Actor who got the part: John Cassavetes

The Magnificent Seven
Considered for the role of Vin.
Actor who got the part: Steve McQueen


 Vincent Perez BACK TO TOP  
Basic Instinct 2: Risk Addiction
Vincent Perez was considered for the part of Dr Andrew Glass.
Actor who got the part: David Morrisey


 Anthony Perkins BACK TO TOP  
East of Eden
Perkins auditioned for director Elia Kazan, who didn't give him the role but who offered him the chance to take over the lead role in the Kazan-directed Broadway stage smash hit "Tea and Sympathy."
Actor who got the part: James Dean

The Godfather
Anthony Perkins auditioned for the roles of Tom Hagen and Sonny Corleone.

Some Like It Hot
He auditioned for the role won by Tony Curtis.
Actor who got the part: Tony Curtis

West Side Story
Was considered to play "Tony."
Actor who got the part: Richard Beymer


 Elizabeth Perkins BACK TO TOP  
A Few Good Men
Elizabeth Perkins auditioned for the role of Joanne Galloway.
Actor who got the part: Demi Moore

When Harry Met Sally...
Elizabeth Perkins turned down the role saying it should go to a nicer girl.
Actor who got the part: Meg Ryan


 Matthew Perry BACK TO TOP  
Independence Day
Perry turned down the Jimmy Wilder role.
Actor who got the part: Harry Connick Jr.

Lost in Space
Matthew Perry was originally offered the part of Don West.
Actor who got the part: Matt LeBlanc


 Jon Pertwee BACK TO TOP  
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen
Was considered for the role of the Baron.
Actor who got the part: John Neville


 Joe Pesci BACK TO TOP  
Donnie Brasco
Pesci was considered to play Nicky early on.
Actor who got the part: Bruno Kirby

Find Me Guilty
Joe Pesci was considered for the role of Jack DiNorscio.
Actor who got the part: Vin Diesel

The Godfather: Part II
Joe Pesci was reportedly considered for the role of Clemenza.
Actor who got the part: Bruno Kirby

Judge Dredd
Pesci was the first choice to play Fergie.
Actor who got the part: Rob Schneider

The Two Jakes
Pesci was considered for the role of Jake Berman.
Actor who got the part: Harvey Keitel


 Bernadette Peters BACK TO TOP  
Nashville
Turned down the role of the red dot-fixated would-be country singing star immortalized by Barbara Harris in director Robert Altman's masterful film.
Actor who got the part: Barbara Harris


 William Petersen BACK TO TOP  
Goodfellas
William Petersen was reportedly considered for the role of Henry Hill.
Actor who got the part: Ray Liotta

Heat
William Petersen turned down a role in Heat.

Platoon
Petersen was offered a role in Platoon but opted instead for the TV film "Long Gone," claiming it's the most fun he's ever had doing a film.


 Joanna Pettet BACK TO TOP  
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
Turned down the role of "Etta" because she was pregnant.
Actor who got the part: Katharine Ross


 Lori Petty BACK TO TOP  
Demolition Man
Lori Petty was replaced by Sandra Bullock to play Lt. Lenina Huxley.
Actor who got the part: Sandra Bullock


 Michelle Pfeiffer BACK TO TOP  
Basic Instinct
Michelle Pfeiffer turned down the lead role of Catherine in Basic Instinct.
Actor who got the part: Sharon Stone

Batman
Tim Burton reportedly wanted Pfeiffer to play Vicki Vale.
Actor who got the part: Kim Basinger

Betrayed
Michelle Pfeiffer was considered to play the lead.
Actor who got the part: Debra Winger

The Bonfire of the Vanities
According to Julie Salamon's book "Bonfire of the Vanities Goes to Hollywood," Michelle Pfeiffer turned down the female lead.
Actor who got the part: Melanie Griffith

Bugsy
Michelle turned down the role of Virginia Hill.
Actor who got the part: Annette Bening

Casino
Michelle Pfeiffer was considered for the role of Ginger.
Actor who got the part: Sharon Stone

Catwoman
Michelle Pfeiffer turned down an offer to reprise her role as Catwoman.
Actor who got the part: Halle Berry

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe
Michelle turned down the part of the White Witch.
Actor who got the part: Tilda Swinton

Dick Tracy
Pfeiffer was one of the actresses briefly considered for the role of Breathless.
Actor who got the part: Madonna

Disclosure
Michelle turned down the role of Meredith Johnson.
Actor who got the part: Demi Moore

Evita
Pfeiffer was considered for the role of Eva Peron (when Oliver Stone was in talks to direct).
Actor who got the part: Madonna

A Few Good Men
Rob Reiner has said that Michelle Pfeiffer was the original choice for the female lead, but that the studio wanted a romance between her and Tom Cruise's characters. the script was unchanged, and the part went to a "tougher" actress.
Actor who got the part: Demi Moore

The Grifters
Michelle Pfeiffer was considered for the role of Lilly Dillon.
Actor who got the part: Anjelica Huston

Infamous
Dropped out of the production about Truman Capote, in which she would have played chic socialite and wife of director Howard Hawks, Slim Keith.
Actor who got the part: Hope Davis

Lorenzo's Oil
Michelle Pfeiffer dropped out of the female lead role in the medical drama directed by George Miller.
Actor who got the part: Susan Sarandon

Mr. Jones
Michelle Pfeiffer turned down the lead role in order to play Catwoman.
Actor who got the part: Lena Olin

A Prairie Home Companion
Had been announced as one of the stars of director Robert Altman's film, playing a 'mysterious angel of death.'.
Actor who got the part: Virginia Madsen

Pretty Woman
Michelle was offered the part of Vivian, but didn't like the tone of the script.
Actor who got the part: Julia Roberts

Pulp Fiction
Pfeiffer was strongly considered to play Mia Wallace.
Actor who got the part: Uma Thurman

The Silence of the Lambs
Michelle Pfeiffer turned down the lead role of Clarice Starling.

Sleepless in Seattle
Pfeiffer was considered to play Annie.
Actor who got the part: Meg Ryan

Thelma and Louise
Pfeiffer and Jodie Foster were originally chosen for the leads, but preproduction took to long and both actresses had to drop out.
Actor who got the part: Geena Davis

Urban Cowboy
Michelle Pfeiffer tried out for the role of Sissy, eventually played by Debra Winger.
Actor who got the part: Debra Winger

Valmont
Michelle was offered the role of the Marquise de Merteuil in this film, but declined so she could play Madame Marie de Tourvel in Dangerous Liaisons instead.
Actor who got the part: Annette Bening

Witness for The Prosecution (2004)
Michelle was set to star as Christine Helm Vole in a remake of the Billy Wilder classic, with a screenplay by David E. Kelly.
Actor who got the part: Film Not Made

Working Girl
Pfeiffer was considered for one of the female leads.


 Mekhi Phifer BACK TO TOP  
Hotel Rwanda
Phifer was turned down for the role of Paul.
Actor who got the part: Don Cheadle

Love & Basketball
Phifer turned down the part of Quincy McCall due to a schedule conflict. He was replaced by Omar Epps.
Actor who got the part: Omar Epps


 Ryan Phillippe BACK TO TOP  
Mindhunters
Phillippe was originally offered a headlining role but declined.

The Patriot
Phillippe was going to play the role of Mel Gibson's son, but Heath Ledger got the part.
Actor who got the part: Heath Ledger

Shadowboxer
Ryan Phillippe turned down the lead role. Cuba Gooding Jr. replaced him.
Actor who got the part: Cuba Gooding Jr.

Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones
One of the finalists for the role of Anakin (and widely rumored to be the runner-up), but eventually vetoed by George Lucas due to his age.
Actor who got the part: Hayden Christensen

Unfaithful
Offered the role of Paul but it was decided that the sexy lover should be European instead of American.
Actor who got the part: Olivier Martinez


 Bijou Phillips BACK TO TOP  
Zodiac
The role of Linda Ferrin was initially played by Bijou Phillips. Her scenes needed to be re-shot but Phillips was not available due scheduling conflicts, so the role went to Clea DuVall.
Actor who got the part: Clea DuVall


 Lou Diamond Phillips BACK TO TOP  
The Matrix
Lou Diamond Phillips' was sent the script, but was later told by his agent that the movie would flop.
Actor who got the part: Keanu Reeves


 Todd Phillips BACK TO TOP  
Borat
Director Todd Phillips was working on Borat but left in 2005 over creative differences.
Actor who got the part: Larry Charles


 Joaquin Phoenix BACK TO TOP  
Brokeback Mountain
The great Phoenix had been mentioned to star in the pioneering love story.
Actor who got the part: Heath Ledger

Hollywoodland
Auditioned for the role of the detective.
Actor who got the part: Adrien Brody

Willard
Joaquin Phoenix turned down the lead role of Willard.
Actor who got the part: Crispin Glover


 River Phoenix BACK TO TOP  
The Basketball Diaries
This project was delayed several times with many choices over the years: Matt Dillon, Eric Stoltz, Anthony Michael Hall, and then River Phoenix. Unfortunately, River passed away and the part was finally given to Leonardo DiCaprio.
Actor who got the part: Leonardo DiCaprio

Broken Dreams
According to the River Phoenix biography, by Barry C. Lawrence, the director John Boorman had wanted River to star in this futuristic drama revolving around magic... River died, and the film has consequently not been made.
Actor who got the part: None

The Crow
River Phoenix turned down the role of Eric Draven.
Actor who got the part: Brandon Lee

Dark Blood
Dark Blood is a film that was never finished because it's star River Phoenix died during production.
Actor who got the part: Film Abandoned

Dead Poets Society
River Phoenix reportedly wanted the role of the actor who commits suicide.
Actor who got the part: Robert Sean Leonard

Interview with the Vampire
River Phoenix was cast to play The Interviewer, but he passed away before filming began.
Actor who got the part: Christian Slater

A River Runs Through It
River Phoenix was beat out for the role of Paul by Brad Pitt.
Actor who got the part: Brad Pitt

Safe Passage
River Phoenix was designated to play the character of Izzy Singer,but Sean Astin got the part after he died.
Actor who got the part: Sean Astin

Titanic
Cameron admitted in an interview in 1998 that he 'always admired Phoenix' and would have condsiered him for the role.
Actor who got the part: Leonardo DiCaprio

Total Eclipse
Phoenix was set to star before his death.
Actor who got the part: Leonardo DiCaprio


 Irving Pichel BACK TO TOP  
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
Paramount executive wanted character actor Pichel for the title roles but director Rouben Mamoulian insisted on Fredric March, who wound up winning an Academy Award for his performance.
Actor who got the part: Fredric March


 Mary Pickford BACK TO TOP  
Life with Father
The silent film star made several tests for this role and wanted it as a comeback vehicle, but Dunne was chosen instead.
Actor who got the part: Irene Dunne

Storm Center
Pickford briefly considered coming out of retirement to play the lead in this drama about book burning.
Actor who got the part: Bette Davis

Sunset Blvd.
Director Billy Wilder went personally to offer the "Norma Desmond" role to Pickford, arguably the greatest and most powerful of all female silent film stars.
Actor who got the part: Gloria Swanson


 Walter Pidgeon BACK TO TOP  
Rebecca
Considered as a very strong contender to play the aristocratic, troubled hero of Alfred Hitchcock's film version of the popular Daphne Du Maurier bestseller.
Actor who got the part: Laurence Olivier


 David Hyde Pierce BACK TO TOP  
Sex, Lies, and Videotape
Auditioned for the role of "John."
Actor who got the part: Peter Gallagher


 Louise Randall Pierson BACK TO TOP  
Mildred Pierce
Warner Bros contract writer Louise Randall Pierson worked on the screenplay but got no screen credit.
Actor who got the part: Ranald MacDougall


 Rosamund Pike BACK TO TOP  
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
Rosamund Pike turned down the role of Rita Skeeter so she could portray Jane Bennett in 'Pride and Prejudice.'
Actor who got the part: Miranda Richardson


 Nova Pilbeam BACK TO TOP  
Rebecca
Alfred Hitchcock resisted pressure by producer David O. Selznick to cast the young actress who had starred for the director in "The Man Who Knew Too Much" and "Young and Innocent."
Actor who got the part: Joan Fontaine


 Jada Pinkett-Smith BACK TO TOP  
Soul Food
Jada Pinkett-Smith was considerd to play the youngest sister Bird.

X-Men
Jada Pinkett-Smith was once considered for the role of Storm but turned it down.
Actor who got the part: Halle Berry


 Brad Pitt BACK TO TOP  
About a Boy
Brad Pitt turned down the lead role of Will.
Actor who got the part: Hugh Grant

Alexander
Brad Pitt was considered for the role of Hephaestion, but turned down the role due to personal concerns with the character.

All the Pretty Horses
Turned down the role of John Grady Cole in the movie version of Cormac McCarthy's fine novel.
Actor who got the part: Matt Damon

Almost Famous
The role of Russell was originally written for Brad Pitt who dropped out saying "I just don't get it enough to do it."
Actor who got the part: Billy Crudup

Ambrose Chapel
Pitt, Liam Neeson, Tea Leoni, Martin Sheen and Madonna were reportedly attached to this 'psychological thriller' to be directed by Brian DePalma. Never got off the ground.
Actor who got the part: Project Never Got Made

American Psycho
Pitt was offered the lead role at one point but turned it down.
Actor who got the part: Christian Bale

Apollo 13
Brad Pitt turned down Apollo 13 in order to do Se7en.

Backdraft
Pitt was reportedly considered for the lead role.
Actor who got the part: William Baldwin

The Bourne Identity
The writer originally had Brad Pitt in mind for the part.
Actor who got the part: Matt Damon

Bride & Prejudice
Brad Pitt could not accept the role of Mr. Darcy due to conflicting schedules.
Actor who got the part: Martin Henderson

The Chamber
Actually committed to the film but backed out along with director Ron Howard.
Actor who got the part: Chris O'Donnell

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Brad Pitt was turned down for the role of Willy Wonka.
Actor who got the part: Johnny Depp

Cold Mountain
Brad Pitt was considered for the role of Inman.
Actor who got the part: Jude Law

The Departed
Pitt was cast as Sullivan but dropped out. He did continue to produce the film.
Actor who got the part: Matt Damon

The Devil's Advocate
Brad Pitt was originally set to play Kevin back when Joel Schumacher was signed on to direct.
Actor who got the part: Keanu Reeves

The Fountain
Pitt pulled out of Darren Aronofsky's sci-fi drama and did "Troy" instead.
Actor who got the part: Hugh Jackman

From Hell
Brad Pitt was considered for the lead role of Inspector Fred Abberline.
Actor who got the part: Johnny Depp

Heathers
Brad Pitt auditioned for the role of J.D., but the producer and director thought he was too sweet looking for the dark character.
Actor who got the part: Christian Slater

The Legend of Bagger Vance
Pitt turned down the role of Junuh.
Actor who got the part: Matt Damon

The Matrix
According to an interview with Matrix composer Don Davis, the studio wanted Brad Pitt or Val Kilmer for the lead role.
Actor who got the part: Keanu Reeves

Rock Star
Brad Pitt was originally considered for the part of Chris "Izzy" Cole.
Actor who got the part: Mark Wahlberg

The Shawshank Redemption
Brad Pitt was intended for the role of Tommy Williams.
Actor who got the part: Gil Bellows

A Simple Plan
According to Vanity Fair, Pitt was offered the lead role but passed because he did not want to do another depressing story after Interview with the Vampire and Legends of the Fall.
Actor who got the part: Bill Paxton

Sleepy Hollow
Brad Pitt was reportedly considered for the role of Ichabod Crane.
Actor who got the part: Johnny Depp

Snatch
Brad Pitt reportedly was going to play Turkish but took the part of Mickey the Pikey instead.
Actor who got the part: Jason Statham

State of Play
The actor withdrew from the production purportedly because he was not happy with the screenplay.
Actor who got the part: Russell Crowe

The Thin Red Line
Brad Pitt was auditioned for the role of Pvt Witt.
Actor who got the part: James Caviezel

A Time to Kill
Seriously considered for the lead role of Jake Brigance (Matt McConaughey).

Titanic
Supposedly considered for the lead role of Jack Dawson.
Actor who got the part: Leonardo DiCaprio

True Romance
Brad Pitt states in the DVD commentary that he was originally offered a "much bigger part" (presumably Clarence) but decided to take the role of the stoner Floyd instead.
Actor who got the part: Christian Slater

Unfaithful
Offered the role of the lover, Paul.
Actor who got the part: Olivier Martinez


 Jeremy Piven BACK TO TOP  
High Fidelity
Piven was considered to be in High Fidelity, but was passed over in favor of Jack Black. This supposedly led to some tension between the two.
Actor who got the part: Jack Black

Red Dragon
Jeremy Piven was considered for the role of Dolarhyde.
Actor who got the part: Ralph Fiennes


 Dana Plato BACK TO TOP  
The Blue Lagoon
Dana Plato (Kimberly from Diff'rent Strokes) reportedly turned down the lead role of Emmeline.
Actor who got the part: Brooke Shields


 Suzanne Pleshette BACK TO TOP  
The Collector
Considered to play the leading female role in director William Wyler's psychological thriller.
Actor who got the part: Samantha Eggar

West Side Story
Was considered for a major role.
Actor who got the part: Natalie Wood


 Joan Plowright BACK TO TOP  
The Grass Harp
Piper Laurie said in an interview that Joan Plowright was originally slated to play the role of Dolly.
Actor who got the part: Piper Laurie


 Amanda Plummer BACK TO TOP  
Agnes of God
The brilliant Amanda Plummer was passed over by director Norman Jewison for the part of Sister Agnes, although she had originated it on stage and won a Tony.
Actor who got the part: Meg Tilly


 Christopher Plummer BACK TO TOP  
Doctor Dolittle (1967)
The actor was hired for the title role when Rex Harrison tried to drop out after the departure from the project of original screenwriter, Alan jay Lerner. When Harrison got lured back, Plummer was paid full salary.
Actor who got the part: Rex Harrison

The Ipcress File
Considered a frontrunner to play spy "Harry Palmer," Plummer dropped out of the competition to star in "The Sound of Music."
Actor who got the part: Michael Caine


 Amy Poehler BACK TO TOP  
The Heartbreak Kid
Amy Poehler was cast as the female lead but later dropped out.
Actor who got the part: Malin Akerman


 Sidney Poitier BACK TO TOP  
The Owl and the Pussycat
Barbra Streisand wanted Poitier as her co-star in the comedy, but studio bosses were nervous that audiences wouldn't accept an interracial couple.
Actor who got the part: Geoge Segal

Straw Dogs
Director Sam Peckinpah considered him for the leading role in his enormously controversial, influential movie.
Actor who got the part: Dustin Hoffman


 Roman Polanski BACK TO TOP  
Schindler's List
Roman Polanski turned down a chance to direct the film because it hit to close to home. Polanski was a Holocaust victim until the age of 8, when he escaped from the Krakow Ghetto.
Actor who got the part: Steven Spielberg


 Sydney Pollack BACK TO TOP  
Ocean's Eleven
Pollack was considered to play Reuben in the remake of Ocean's Eleven.
Actor who got the part: Elliot Gould


 Sarah Polley BACK TO TOP  
Almost Famous
Had accepted the part of Penny but dropped out to do another film.
Actor who got the part: Kate Hudson

Gangs of New York
Had the role of Jenny but lost it to Cameron Diaz when Scorsese was forced to go with a more bankable star.
Actor who got the part: Cameron Diaz


 Ellen Pompeo BACK TO TOP  
Clerks II
Ellen Pompeo was courted by the makers of Clerks II to play the role of Becky but she decided she didn't want to infringe apon the potential commitment or scheduling of "Grey's Anatomy".
Actor who got the part: Rosario Dawson


 Paulina Porizkova BACK TO TOP  
Goldeneye
Paulina Porizkova turned down the role of Natalya.
Actor who got the part: Izabella Scorupco


 Natalie Portman BACK TO TOP  
Almost Famous
According to director Cameron Crowe, Portman auditioned for the part of Penny.
Actor who got the part: Kate Hudson

Anywhere But Here
Originally turned down the part of Ann because of a required nude scene. The script was rewritten to get her back.

Cold Mountain
Before being cast as Sara, Natalie Portman was considered for the role of Ada.
Actor who got the part: Nicole Kidman

The Constant Gardener
Natalie Portman reportedly passed on the role of Tessa.
Actor who got the part: Rachel Weisz

Elizabethtown
Natalie was considered for a role in Cameron Crowe's Elizabethtown.

Head in the Clouds
Portman turned down the lead role 2 weeks before pre-production because she didn't feel she was right for the part.
Actor who got the part: Charlize Theron

The Horse Whisperer
Natalie Portman turned down the part to do a stint on broadway instead.

The Ice Storm
Natalie Portman turned down the role of Wendy before it went to Christina Ricci.
Actor who got the part: Christina Ricci

Little Women
Natalie Portman tried out for the movie but didn't get a part.

Lolita
Natalie Portman turned down the lead because she disagreed with the sexual content.

Romeo + Juliet
Reportedly the first choice for Juliet.

Superman Returns
Portman was reportedly considered for the role of Lois Lane.
Actor who got the part: Kate Bosworth

X-Men
Natalie Portman turned down the part of Rogue.


 Parker Posey BACK TO TOP  
Jerry Maguire
Parker Posey was considered to play Dorothy.

Speed
Parker Posey auditioned for Speed and didn't get it. She's told the story on several talk shows, about asking for a plate to use as a steering wheel for her auditon.
Actor who got the part: Sandra Bullock


 Monica Potter BACK TO TOP  
Boys and Girls
Monica Potter was originally cast as Katie.
Actor who got the part: Monica Arnold

Gangs of New York
Potter was considered for the role of Jenny Everdeane.
Actor who got the part: Cameron Diaz


 Dick Powell BACK TO TOP  
Double Indemnity
Wanted the role of Walter Neff but had previous commitment to another studio.


 Jane Powell BACK TO TOP  
Love Me or Leave Me
Singer Ruth Etting wanted Powell to portray her on film since Powell was "dainty," like the real Etting herself.
Actor who got the part: Doris Day

Singin' in the Rain
Eventually considered "too old" for the role of newcomer "Kathy Selden."
Actor who got the part: Debbie Reynolds


 William Powell BACK TO TOP  
Forever, Darling
MGM had offered the debonair Powell and frequent costar Myrna Loy this script about a long-married couple and their relationship issues.
Actor who got the part: Desi Arnaz

Lady for a Day
The dashing, debonair MGM star was wanted by director Frank Capra to play "Dave the Dude," but a loanout could not be arranged.
Actor who got the part: Warren William

Rebecca
Director Alfred Hitchcock was very intrigued by the possibility of attracting the suave, debonair comedian to play his dark, tortured hero with a secret.
Actor who got the part: Laurence Olivier

Romeo and Juliet (1936)
When Barrymore's drinking started causing problems on this production, Powell was approached to replace him in the role of Mercutio. Powell, a close friend of Barrymore's, refused.
Actor who got the part: John Barrymore

Shadow of a Doubt
Director Alfred Hitchcock won the interest of suave, debonair star Powell to play the "Merry Widow" murderer but Powell's studio, MGM, quashed the idea.
Actor who got the part: Joseph Cotten


 Tyrone Power BACK TO TOP  
The Barretts of Wimpole Street
Power was thought of for the role of Robert Browning when it was to have co-starred he and Deborah Kerr.
Actor who got the part: Bill Travers

From Here to Eternity
Harry Cohn was always desperate to get Tyrone Power for a film, but could never get him away from Zanuck. He finally got his chance and offered Power the lead in From Here to Eternity, but Power turned it down to do a play.
Actor who got the part: Burt Lancaster

Golden Boy
Tyrone Power was offered many roles during his career - and while he was at Fox, Darryl Zanuck turned them all down. This includes the lead in "Golden Boy" that went to William Holden.
Actor who got the part: William Holden

Gone with the Wind
20th Century Fox head Darryl F. Zanuck foolishly and selfishly denied the makers of this Civil War classic epic the chance to borrow Power from Fox so that he could play Ashley Wilkes.
Actor who got the part: Leslie Howard

Kings Row
Power was offered the role of Paris in Kings Row, but Darryl Zanuck, furious that Power ended up on screen such a short time when he lent him to MGM for Marie Antoinette, refused to ever lend him out again.
Actor who got the part: Robert Cummings

The Robe
Studio bosses offered the "Marcellus Gallio" role to Power, but he instead chose to do a stage play.
Actor who got the part: Richard Burton

Solomon and Sheba
Power had filmed nearly half the movie when he collapsed and died after filming a dueling sequence.
Actor who got the part: Yul Brynner

Viva Zapata!
The major star and heartthrob was the original choice to play Mexican revolutionary Emiliano Zapata for director Elia Kazan.
Actor who got the part: Marlon Brando


 Otto Preminger BACK TO TOP  
Fahrenheit 451
Novelist Ray Bradbury, having had a difficult experience making "Moby Dick" with John Huston, did not want yet another difficult director to obtain the screen rights to one of his most famous novels.
Actor who got the part: Francois Truffaut


 Paula Prentiss BACK TO TOP  
Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice
A strong contender for the role of uptight Alice.
Actor who got the part: Dyan Cannon


 Brian Presley BACK TO TOP  
Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones
Brian Presley auditioned for the role of Anakin Skywalker.
Actor who got the part: Hayden Christensen


 Elvis Presley